Crossing the street — what are the odds?
I needed to go to the store last weekend, and I thought I’d walk. It isn’t far and walking is good for you. I did it all the time when I lived in a city.
But to get to the store I have to cross one big street. There’s a light and a crosswalk, but it’s one of those streets where the drivers don’t expect pedestrians. And there’s always cars turning left and right even when there’s a cross signal. It’s a complicated wide busy intersection.
I’ve crossed this street before however, and I’ve never had a close call. There’s a lot going on, but I try to be super careful. I feel the risk. I wouldn’t want my kid to have to cross this street.
So I’m thinking, what if I had to cross this street every day for, say 10 years. I’d be crossing thousands of times. What are the odds that I’d be hit by a car, have really bad luck just once in all those chances?
Let’s say the odds of being hit are one in 100 million. If I cross 5 thousand times, my odds of being hit are about one in 20 thousand. I’m a little uncomfortable with that, but it feels like an acceptable risk for something spread out over 10 years.
But I think the odds are probably somewhat worse than that, maybe even as high as one in 10,000. Which would mean I have a pretty good chance of being hit over 10 years. Which negates all the health benefits of walking.
And if I shouldn’t be crossing that street every day for 10 years, I probably shouldn’t be crossing at all without a good reason.
So the problem is that you can’t rely on intuition to decide whether something like this is safe. Intuition isn’t very good at distinguishing between 1 in 10,000 and 1 in 10,000,000. Intuition isn’t very good at summing odds over 10 years. You have to think it out.
Now all I have to do is find out what the odds really are.
Comments
40 Responses to “Crossing the street — what are the odds?”
The CDC has some excellent information on how many people died in the US from various causes.
161 deaths in 2006: V03 “Pedestrian injured in collision with car, pickup truck, or van”
418 deaths in 2006: V05 “Pedestrian injured in collision with railway train or railway vehicle”
4262 deaths in 2006: V43 “Car occupant injured in collision with car, pickup truck, or van”
631,250 deaths in 2006: “Heart Disease”
Imagine that we talked about something with a time proportional to how many of our neighbors that something has killed.
Then for every minute we talk about getting hit while walking across the street, we would talk for 30 minutes about car accidents, and 65 hours about heart disease.
David,
You’re probably right. The health benefits of walking probably out-weigh the risk of being hit crossing that street.
But that 4000-to-one ratio of deaths due to heart-disease vs car-smack is not a slam-dunk argument in this case. Of the ~2000 people in my neighborhood, only about 100 ever seem to walk anywhere at all. (I’m guessing. I walk around most days, at various times, and I see the same 20 people over and over.) And nobody ever crosses that street. So very very few people ever get the opportunity to get killed as a pedestrian.
At least in the suburbs.
Let’s say that instead of crossing that street I had to swing on a rope across a deep chasm every day. I’m reassured because the CDC tells me that only 2 people/year are killed doing this. But later on I find out that only about 200 people in the entire country ever swing across chasms at all, and many of them only a few times a year.
So I guess I’m saying this is an exceptional activity, and I don’t know how risky it is because so few people partake. Maybe crossing that street is as risky as skydiving? If you’re a skydiver, what’re your odds every time you jump? 0.00009? Or 0.0000001? There’s a big difference. I’ll take the later, but not the former.
I actually did get hit by a car crossing a street like that and I wasn’t injured at all. Maybe you should be looking at more variables than whether you will get hit.
Que vous soyez de passage de la route, ou des sentiers pédestres, porteront nos chaussures. S’il vous plaît regardez nos chaussures.
Set your own life more easy get the credit loans and all you require.
My husband was hit and killed as a pedestrian in Cape Coral Florida. Florida is the number one kill state for pedestrians. We worked In Manhattan for years with no problems. Look twice before you cross, remember the car usually wins! Take care!
I discovered your blog web site on google and examine
just a few of your early posts. Continue to maintain up the
superb operate. I only extra up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader.
Seeking for forward to reading more out of you later on!
real estate is the most lucrative company, any other man can make a fortune in real estate company.
soem online pages that present download games have viruses and spywares on it.
so make sure to have some antivirus on your PC,,
There have been several posts out there near this, I do believe taking there reference could experience made
this spot or article actually informative. Thats not me expression
this information is poor quality. Simply I need to pronounce
the fact that info provided here was unique, simply rebuild more near execute, supporting to former
information will receive been really first-rate.
That the points you have touched listed below have been
really important, thus Ill spot a whole lot of of that the information here to make this really best for entirely the newbies here.
Thank you this info. Actually helpful!
Pretty nice post, thanks for that the awesome article.
Im having troubles subscribing to your website pages feed.
Thought Id let you recognize
of course, diamond rings would always be that the
best type of wedding rings that you’ll hand over your wife
drug addiction is a menace to the society, it destroys lives and it destroys
the community
My neighbor and I had been just debating this specific topic,
he is normally searching to prove me incorrect. Your view on this is outstanding and exactly how I truly think.
I just now mailed him this blog to show him your point of view.
After looking over your website I bookmarked and will be coming back to figure out your new
posts!
When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several e-mails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that service? Cheers!
Does anybody know of any other treatments that actually works have been haemorrhoids.
I dont wish to go to the doctors I feel very embarrassed.
I can see you to have been an expert at your field!
I am launching a website soon, and your info will be very useful
for me. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all that
the success in your business.
Helpful info. Fortunate me I discovered your web site accidentally, and I am shocked why this accident didn’t happened in advance! I bookmarked it.
assisted living is nice if you got some people and a
home that cares greatly to it can be occupants
When visiting domains, i always look for a very nice content just like yours ,
Good post. I will be facing many of these issues
as well..
well, whenever you really would like to be healthy,
i believe that veggan foods have been the best ‘
Shes a confused woman who gets involved in all the action and later on falls for Roy.
It’s enormous that you are getting thoughts from this piece of writing as well as from our argument made at this place.
Hmm it seems like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I
guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any suggestions for first-time blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.
abstract art have share some of it’s unique beauty when it comes to art. i such as abstract art as it’s mysterious
I went over this website and I think you have a lot of superb information, bookmarked .
i use lamp shades with CFL ubls instead of incandescent lamps, that they have been much cooler and uses less electricity“
I Just stopped by to say your article is great.
That the clarity in your post is merely spectacular and i can assume youre
an expert on this subject. Excellent with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed
to keep present with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and
please continue that the enjoyable work.
Nicely, that’s certainly fine, nonetheless how about further alternatives weve here Can you mind composing yet a different article relating to them all furthermore Appreciate it!
While looking on Dating I found your blog, there have been some first-rate posts here and
Ill be checking back
Oh i actually envy the system you post topics, how i wish i could
write like that.
Thank you for making that the trustworthy attempt to speak about
this. I think very sturdy approximately it and wish to read more.
If its OK, as you achieve extra intensive wisdom, would you mind including extra articles very similar to this one
with additional info It will be extraordinarily useful and helpful for me and my friends.
I will invite all my friends to your blog, you actually got a great blog.
,
Well, Objective, im not so i have been in agreement with all in
this article, then again you do make a important comprehension with
this issue. I may instruct myself
cable agencies are also offering broadband internet in this day and age and that the
cost is easy on the pocket too.,
You can find definitely lots of details for instance that to take
into consideration. That´s a great point to bring
up. I present you with the thoughts above as universal inspiration in spite of
this clearly youll get a hold of questions for example the one you bring up where that the most essential factor can be working in honest excellent faith.
I don´t be acquainted with if best practices have emerged around things for instance that, in spite of this I am certain that your
job is clearly identified as a fair game.
I simply just couldnt leave your website just before saying that I
really enjoyed the first-rate quality information you hand over to your visitors Definitely will be back often to
check on up on brand new stuff you post!
used trucks have been sometimes expensive and it can be quite hard to discover a excellent bargain whenever you dont lookup heavily“
Thanks a lot for the efforts to have decided to put these things together on this site.
Janet and i also vastly liked your suggestions through that the articles
with certain things. I understand that you have a quantity of demands on your program therefore the fact that an person something like you took just as much time for instance you
did to steer people along that the lines of us through this article is even highly prized.